3-9 July 2015 #765

Man in a hurry

Tufan Neupane in Himal Khabarpatrika, 28 June-4 July

Chief Justice Ram Kumar Prasad Shah is retiring on 6 July, and he is being replaced by Supreme Court’s senior most Justice Kalyan Shrestha.

But Shah looks like a man in a hurry. After acquitting fake doctor Yeshe Lama from Humla who had embezzled $1 million from an American charity earlier this year, he is now embroiled in a scam to purchase computer equipment in violation of the Public Procurement Act 2007, and hiring employees on two-year contract against the SC’s own recruitment process.

On 24 December 2014, the apex court’s Information Technology Committee (ITC), also headed by Shah, had called a tender to buy 375 desktop computers.

International Electronic Concerns (IEC), a Kathmandu-based supplier, submitted a proposal to sell desktop computers per piece at Rs 60,630 (excluding VAT).

But the ITC rejected the IEC’s lowest-price bid and accepted another proposal by World Distribution Nepal (WDN), which quoted much higher price of Rs 71,400 per piece (excluding VAT).

The ITC had to pay Rs 4.38 million more to purchase 475 desktop computers from the WDN. The IEC moved the court, arguing the ITC violated the article 47 (6) of the act, which says the lowest bidder’s proposal should be accepted. But the SC quashed the IEC’s petition, dubbing it ‘baseless’ on 5 May.

Article 25 (3) of the same act stipulates that the price at which goods are procured should not be 15 per cent higher than the lowest bidder’s proposal. But the ITC cunningly disqualified the IEC and other low-price bidders by adding a line in its tender notice: ‘data security and chassis intelligent management tool’.

Computers of all brands with ‘operating system windows -8.1% have this tool but ‘chassis intelligent management tool’ is mentioned only in Dell computers, and the WDN supplies Dells.

Observers close to the investigation say the tender was tailor made only for Dell. The Act says particular details, signs and words cannot be mentioned in tender notices to make only a few bidders eligible without justifying the reasons.

Shah was ITC chief even when he was not Chief Justice. He was dismissed as the ITC chief by former Chief Justice Ram Prasad Shrestha, but was later reappointed by Chief Justice Damodar Sharma. Chief Justices usually do not head any SC committees, but Shah did not resign from the post even after becoming Chief Justice.

Shah also seems desperate to hire 75 employees, including information technology director, managers and maintenance officers, on two-year contracts before his exit. On 21 April, the SC published a vacancy notice and 472 candidates submitted their applications.

The SC follows a long process of written exam, interview and technical exam to hire contract employees. But this time, the SC short-listed 279 applicants for interview without taking their written exam. Several associations of the SC employees say the recruitment process was cut short to hire specific people before Shah’s retirement.

Interestingly, the ITC’s System Network Administrator Bishwas Khatiwada, who is a member of the SC’s recruitment committee, is among the short-listed 279 applicants and is ready to be interviewed for the post of manager. Interestingly, the ITC had purchased desktop computers from the WDN based on an evaluation report prepared by Khatiwada.

Read also:

Getting away with (almost) anything