Nepali Times
Review
Comrade Parvati’s verbal violence


A multi-storey building of the Nepal Engineers' Association (NEA) at Pulchok is now almost complete, towering over modest structures in the vicinity. During the years it was being built, Hisila Yami was busy mobilising women across Nepal.

The NEA tower was partly designed by a young and energetic architect who used to bicycle around town collecting membership dues as the NEA's treasurer. After democracy in 1990, the NEA honoured Hisila's commitment. When Krishna Prasad Bhattarai hesitated-how could a bachelor premier garland a married woman in public-Hisilia had craned her neck to receive the garland and the sindoor with a polite but firm: "Communists don't believe in customs with gender bias."

She showed similar zeal in protesting beauty pageants that came to town with the new market economy. She went off for higher studies in England and returned to go underground soon after. Hisila Yami, the engaged intellectual of the Institute of Engineering, had now become Comrade Parvati.

Her book, People's War and Women's Liberation in Nepal records the confusion of her mind in excruciating detail. She tries to say things she knows to be only partially true, and it shows. The book begins with a prosaic publisher's note probably penned by an aging apparatchik somewhere in Jharkhand. It reads like leaflets of the ex-Soviet Union. The foreword by Chairman Prachanda is shorter but no less platitudinous, and he openly admits the sole purpose of this book in English is propaganda.

Don't bother if you have no stomach for rhetoric straight out of Mao's China of the 1960s. Reading this feels like a spell in a time machine, proof that history repeats itself-as farce.

"I had been a liberal feminist before I became a communist," says Hisila in her foreword. Many activists from Hisila's generation have opened NGOs and mellowed, the fire in their bellies has gone out, but Hisila soldiered on. There is no denying her commitment to the cause, but if you want to find out what makes her tick you won't find any answers in this book.

If she had remained an activist, would things be better or worse for Nepali women? Hard to say. Despite the contribution of women soldiers in the 'People's Liberation Army', their presence in the decision-making body of Maoists is minimal. Pampha Bhushal and Hisila Yami are leaders of the movement, but it is difficult to find a third woman recognised by common Maoist cadre throughout the country.

The photographic section of the book seems to have been inserted at the last moment as an afterthought. They bear no relevance to the text of the book.

nterspersed with Maoisms ("People's War is a total war" and "To be advanced means to do the work of backward") and inane quotes from Marx, the book is dreadfully difficult to read. Even as propaganda it fails because it underestimates the readers' intelligence.

The struggle of man against power, Milan Kundera once said, is the struggle of memory against forgetting. What then is struggle of woman against power? Of forgetfulness against memory? The dialectic shows in the introduction of the author at the beginning of the book.

Ten years after she went into the wilderness, Hisila is back in the city of her forefathers to claim her place at the high table of intellectual debates. During talk-shows on tv, she is surprisingly restrained, but this book is doctrinaire Prachandpath. Hisila is capable of, and should, come out with more logically-argued books if she wants to convince us of the righteousness of her cause. This book does little justice to her learning, understanding and compassion. The right to publicise Prachandpath is all hers, but not with such shoddy prose, at least not when the peace process is on.

CK Lal

People's War and Women's Liberation in Nepal
by Hisila Yami (Comrade Parvati)
Purvaiya Prakashan, Raipur, India 2006
pp: xxviii+187
RS. 200 (paperback)



LATEST ISSUE
638
(11 JAN 2013 - 17 JAN 2013)


ADVERTISEMENT









himalkhabar.com            

NEPALI TIMES IS A PUBLICATION OF HIMALMEDIA PRIVATE LIMITED | ABOUT US | ADVERTISE | SUBSCRIPTION | PRIVACY POLICY | TERMS OF USE | CONTACT