Nepali Times
J B PUN MAGAR
Guest Column
The 2/3 strategy


J B PUN MAGAR


BHANU BHATTARAI

To understand the current nationwide mischief of the Maoists, you have to rewind to the Shaktikhor Tapes of 2008. In it, Pushpa Kamal Dahal taught his comrades to lie. He is caught on candid camera telling his commanders: "You have to keep repeating what is not true, and keep quiet about your real intentions."

Ever since the Maoists resigned from government last year, they have been saying, "We have to get back into government one way or another." It isn't hard to see that this slogan is a decoy. The Maoists are employing the Prachanda Doctrine of "repeating what is not true".

The Maoists have learnt two lessons from the elections and their time in government. First, keep the other parties out of the districts with fear tactics that translate into votes at election time. Second, the Maoists always said "we are in government, but not in power", and next time they will not be satisfied until they have a two-thirds majority. The entire Maoist strategy today revolves around these two mantras, and the goal is an absolute majority in a future legislature.

Being a coalition partner cramped Dahal's style. He couldn't implement any of his revolutionary slogans, and to save himself from internal party pressure he had to go through with the sacking of the army chief in May 2009. He knew the Indians wouldn't like it, Girija Koirala had been consistently warning him not to do it, the president had given ample indications it would backfire. But he pushed it through and paid for the blunder. Everything that has happened since is an attempt to turn the clock back.

After coming to power, the Maoists didn't just drift from their revolutionary goals, they also went soft. Several of the party's coveted ethnic wings split off, calling the leadership 'Bahunist'. The party was even on the verge of splitting. In fact, the Maoist central committee has since concluded that being out of power has actually strengthened the party.
The party's agitations for 'civilian supremacy', the anti-Indian campaign, and the escalating protests against a 'puppet government' must be seen as part of the party's election campaign for the next polls, not an exercise to return to power right now. The idea is to ride the anti-Indian wave, and the results of the Himalmedia poll last week show why this may work:
76 per cent of the respondents (even more in the Tarai) think Nepal's nationality is threatened.

The same poll draws the interesting conclusion that most people blame the Maoists for the present disarray, but also want them to fix it. This indicates an erosion of trust in the other parties that the Maoists also want to capitalise on. They want to keep the cadre engaged nationwide in agitation, struggle and training and have mobilised their ethnic units. They have brought thousands of jobless youth into a stick-and-khukuri force that can stand-in for the YCL if it is disbanded and be useful in future elections.

The Maoists have hogged the headlines and kept rival parties distracted with bruising controversies so that they are restricted to reacting with bland statements. They have always regarded the mainstream media as the next big enemy because of its opposition to violence and totalitarianism. This is why they have decided to cut diamond with diamond by setting up their own print, TV and radio stations.

The Maoists know they have to weaken the strong forces arrayed against them: India, president and the government. They are going after them one by one. The government and India are determined not to allow this to happen.

It is difficult to say whether the Maoists will be successful in their aim of legal state capture, but there should be no doubt in anyone's mind that this is what they are after.

Translated from the 16-31 May issue of Himal Khabarpatrika.



1. saurav
if we look at the other countries like china and singapore then leaders like lee kuan yew and deng xia ping has more or less implemented the totalilarism by using the every good method they have either be media or by arms force or anything. And look at them now, they have built tremendous force. More or less Mr.Prachanda has tried to implement the same things over here too. He has got strong leadership, a bold and large organization and committed teams members. Notheless they are not the best ones, but far better than Makuney and Sujata. So they must be given chance to prove themselves...

2. jange
The maoists and PKD have been given more than one chance and they have proved themselves to be murderers, looters and extortionists.

Nepal can't afford to give them more chances.


3. hange
saurav, I have to agree with jange: the Maoists have been given a chance and all they have done is to destroy, lie, threaten, and cause misery among the people by enforcing a bandh which hurt the very people that they were purportedly representing.  Yes, the Maoists may be bold and large with committed team members, but the question is, what are they committed to?  Anarchy?  Totalitarianism?  Political power at all cost?  The answer is pretty simple:  Yes.

4. Satya Nepali

Don't know what all those ppl are doing cooing over Prashant Jha for a "brilliant analysis" and what not. Here, in JB Pun's words, is where I see an insightful and truthful analysis. The Maoists are not going to stop until they get that absolute majority. A coalition government is not what the Maoists count as being given "a chance". For them, having a chance means having complete control. And they will not rest until they have that. They will exhaust the Nepali populace into giving them that "chance" as per their definition of the word!

...which is why I repeatedly ask: what was/is the *basis* of our intellectuals-civil-society fraternity's belief, since 2006, that the Maoists were/are ready to transform into a normal, civilian party? Why did they so vehemently support the "mainstreaming-the-Maoists" through "safe-landing" (by kicking-out-the-king) agenda?

Our intellectuals have never seriously wrestled with this crucial question. They've gotten away making easy, glib remarks. But they have to be forced to publicly face this crucial question now. Our country is bound to lose at least a decade, if not more, of peace and development due to this one decision of theirs. (We've already lost 4). It is our right to know what made them take such a costly and risky decision? And what made them convince others, the whole nation, to follow their "peaceful-solution" path? They need to be put on the spot and answer the people on these questions. Otherwise they'll keep on with their Lies and keep misleading the people! 

Even intellectuals, civil society, journalists etc. need to be ANSWERABLE to the people, not just the politicians!

 



5. Nice Strategy
great analysis Mr Pun! tells it the way it is. also agree 100% with saurav. 
The current ruling parties have no vision, no bone and most important no mandate. their only defense is calling Maoists names. its amazing how maoists continue to gain strength by the day, standing ground on it own against a sea of powerful organized status quoist forces.


6. Budabaaje
Absolutely right. And let's remember that the King and Army were aware of this 4-5 years ago. That is why they had taken up a hardline stance against the Maoists. What King and Army knew and tried to ward off years ago, our "intellectuals" in NT are only realizing now! Criticize Gyanendra all you like, but he was right about the Maoists all along, and his strategy for dealing with them would have delivered better results. He has been wrongly and unjustly punished. The monarchy should be restored! How can we punish anyone for being right?!

7. ms. bange
no more chance for maoists.

period. (and i'm not talking about the monthly kind)


8. Arthur
I have to partially agree with Satya Nepali. Stripped of the anti-Maoist rhetoric, this author is more insightful than Prashant Jha by pointing out that the Maoists are aiming at "legal state capture" by winning an absolute majority in elections.

How vicious these evil Maoists are! Winning an absolute majority in elections is a totalitarian attack on "loktantrik"!!

The people deserve no more chances! They have already proved that they cannot be trusted by voting for the Maoists once and they will do it again with a bigger majority!!

It is time for the government to dissolve the people and choose a new one!!!

Period!!!!



9. Arthur
jange,

#25
Posted on: 11 MAY 2010 | 2:27 PM NST

#37
Posted on: 11 MAY 2010 | 2:32 PM NST

#24
Posted on: 11 MAY 2010 | 2:33 PM NST

#48 Posted on: 11 MAY 2010 | 2:34 PM NST

#19 Posted on: 11 MAY 2010 | 2:35 PM NST

#40
Posted on: 11 MAY 2010 | 2:42 PM NST
 
#2   Posted on: 11 MAY 2010 | 2:57 PM NST

Is there some point to this cut and paste repetition? Wouldn't it have more impact if you at least pretended to be responding to what others are saying instead of just repeating your mantras?

Are you feeling more isolated now that more people are joining in from different points of view and feel a need to compensate by repetition?

Also I am puzzled, if there is some point to this repetitive chanting, why not also add it to some of the other topics?

You seem to only have last week's mantra at:

#2 
Posted on: 07 MAY 2010 | 3:13 PM NST

and a slight variation on a previous mantra at:

#1
Posted on: 07 MAY 2010 | 3:59 PM NST

Surely you could have added the current mantra to those two and there are even other topics where you haven't said anything at all?

Are you becoming bored and lazy with your assigned duties.

Are you being paid per comment?

Anyway it took you a whole 30 minutes from 2:27 to 2:57 for only 7 repetitions.

Let's see how quickly it can be exposed in all 9 topics with some automation. I'm hoping for only 2 minutes from earliest to latest, but it may depend on the moderation.


10. Mike
Interesting analysis, Mr. Pum!!! if half of what you are saying, we are moving towards dangerous times... do the rest of Nepali politician and intelligentia understand this Maoist approach, I wonder! I shiver to think what might happen if they come with absolute majority... thank u for an interesting view point and boradening our thinking!!

LATEST ISSUE
638
(11 JAN 2013 - 17 JAN 2013)


ADVERTISEMENT



himalkhabar.com            

NEPALI TIMES IS A PUBLICATION OF HIMALMEDIA PRIVATE LIMITED | ABOUT US | ADVERTISE | SUBSCRIPTION | PRIVACY POLICY | TERMS OF USE | CONTACT